This research deals with the situation of grammarians from the recitations. It was common in old and new grammar lesson that the grammarians rejected some of successive Quranic recitation. They refused and criticized number of reciters, but those grammarians were criticized by other grammarians, at the same time.In this research we try to show when the grammarians refused the recitation they did not reject it as a Quranic recitation, but criticized it as a proof that contradicts the Arabic speech.In addition grammarians affirm that the recitation is a prophetic tradition and it exists with what was conveyed from the prophet Muhammad ( Blessing and peace be upon him) not by the opinion but in the same time, they criticized it for contradicting many Arabic evidences.