Commenting on Judicial Provisions via social media ( A Comparative Analysis)

Section: RESEARCH
Published
Aug 4, 2025
Pages
41-71

Abstract

Judicial provisions are one of the most essential stages in a civil case. We usually notice a paragraph concerning comments on judicial decisions in periodicals and legal magazines in case of repeal against judgments. The aim of this paragraph is to show the advantages and disadvantages of judicial provisions of all decrees issued by all courts. The development in electronic and social communication through various electronic means, in the present times has enabled(facilitated) special platforms (opportunities) pages for social communication and legal forums where people comment on judicial provision. However, since these people may not mainly be specialized in the legal field, there is a possibility of their comments on judicial provisions causing problems. This might require clarifications in addition to proposing legal solutions, and suggestive remedies regarding them.

References

  1. - Amended Iraqi Lawyer Law No. (173) of 1965.
  2. - Social media definition. A study available on the global information network, withdrawn from the website https://mawdoo3.com
  3. - The decision of the Iraqi Court of Repeal No. (734) of 6/9/1970 was published in the Judicial Bulletin, Issue Two, 1971.
  4. Ahmed Abu Issa Abdel Hamid, Methodology for Commenting on Judicial Decisions, Sabratha University Scientific Journal, 4th Issue, December, 2018.
  5. Roger Mandari, Commentary on the Judicial Decision on Private Law Issues, translated by Dr. Saadi Ismail Al-Barzanji. The Paths of Law Series, from Saladin University Publications, Erbil, Iraq, 1982.
  6. - The Egyptian Civil and Commercial Procedure Law No. 13 of 1968.
  7. - The website of Al-Mal Al-Masry newspaper, www.almalnews.com
  8. - Zahir Radi. The Use of Social Media in the Arab World. Education Journale, Issue 15, Al-Ahliyya Amman University, Amman, 2003.
  9. Abdul Aziz Abdul Rahman bin Ali Al-Rabiah. Scientific Research: its Truth, Sources, Material, Methods, Writing, Printing and Discussion. Riyadh, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, without publishing house, 1998.
  10. - Al Watan Electronic Gate, https://www.elwatannews.com
  11. - Amended Iraqi Civil Procedure Law No. 83 of 1969.
  12. - Salem Roudhan Al-Mousawi. Legal Center to Create a Page on the Social Networking Site "Facebook" as a Model (A search available on the World Wide Web, withdrawn from the site: https://www.iraqfsc.iq. The Civilized Dialogue - Issue: 5876-2018. / 5/18 - 11:39 Axis: Legal studies and research
  13. Abdel Fattah Mourad, Commentary on the New in the Egyptian Court of Cassation. Without a Publishing House, 2004.
  14. - Adel Youssef Shoukry. How to write legal scientific research and comment on legal texts and judicial decisions, Kufa Journal of Legal and Political Sciences, 2013, Volume 1, Issue 16.
  15. - Amended Iraqi Penal Code No. 111 of 1969.
  16. Abdel Fattah Murad. The Correct Rules of Ethics, Values and Judicial Traditions: A comparative study in man-made laws and Islamic law. Copyright reserved to the author, Edition 1, 2007.
  17. - Abd Al-Fattah Murad. Principles of Commentary on Legal Texts and Judicial Decisions. A research published in the Journal of Justice and Law issued by the Palestinian Center for the Independence of Advocacy and Judiciary (Musawah), September 2007.
  18. - The Amended Judicial Organization Law No. (160) of 1979.
  19. Abdel Fattah Murad. Encyclopedia of Prosecutions, Applied and Technical Criminal Investigation and Interrogation Management. Part 6, Without Publishing House, 2004.
  20. - Amended Iraqi University Service Law No. (23) of 2008.
  21. - Yahya El-Gamal. An article published in the online newspaper Al-Masry Al-Youm, issue on Monday 9/22/2008 Issue No. 1562, available on 3/20/2017 today.almasryalyoum.com.
  22. Abd al-Qadir al-Sheikhly. Scientific Research Rules. House of Culture for Publishing, Jordan Amman, 2nd Edition, 2012.
  23. - Rules of Professional Conduct and its amendments for the year 2016
  24. Omar Al-Toumi Al-Shaibani, "Social Research Curricula," Al-Fateh Complex for Universities, Tripoli, 3rd Edition, 1989.
  25. - The Iraqi Judicial Supervision Authority Law No. (29) of 2016.
  26. Mohamed Al-Arouousi. The Compendium on Legal Methodology. Al-Khattab Press for Printing, Meknes, Morocco, 2009.
  27. Wasim Shafiq Al-Hajjar. The Legal System for Social Media. Published by the Arab Center for Legal and Judicial Research of the Council of Arab Justice Ministers, First Edition, 2017.
  28. Fifth: Judicial decisions
  29. First: books
  30. Fourth: Laws
  31. References
  32. Second: Research, studies and articles
  33. Third: Internet sites
Download this PDF file

Statistics