Withdrawing the hand is a result of the decision to refer the public employee to the judiciary
Abstract
The withdrawal of employment privileges stands as a significant repercussion for an employee's disciplinary transgressions, marking a breach of their legal standing and potentially paving the way for subsequent penalties. These infractions could escalate to judicial referral, potentially resulting in the termination of the employment relationship and the removal of the employee's general status.The determination of whether this termination and loss of status are temporary, as seen in cases involving the withdrawal of privileges and dismissal penalties per the current State Employees Discipline Law, or permanent, as in dismissal penalties defined within the law itself, hinges on the principle that "no crime and no punishment except by a text." This principle, articulated in Article 1 of the Amended Penal Code No. (111) of 1969, emphasizes that acts or omissions merit punishment only in accordance with established laws.Disciplinary penalties are explicitly outlined in Article 8 of the Disciplinary Law for State and Public Sector Employees No. (14) of 1991, as amended. While disciplinary violations are not rigidly specified in type, they generally stem from a breach of public job duties or a violation of its requisites. The administration evaluates the impact of such violations, culminating in the decision to withdraw privileges, especially when opting to refer a public employee to court for serious disciplinary transgressions.
References
- Abdel-Fattah Abdel-Halim, Disciplinary Guarantees in the Public Job, A Comparative Study, The Authorship Press, Without a Year of Publication.
- Abdel Aziz Abdel Moneim Khalifa, canceling the administrative decision and disciplining the public employee, Al-Maaref Establishment for Publishing, Part Two, Alexandria, without a year of printing.
- Abdul Qadir Muhammad Al-Qaisi, The Impact of the Public Employee's Criminal Act on Terminating his Employment Relationship, Al-Sanhouri Library, First Edition, 2011AD.
- Ahmed Mahmoud Ahmed Al-Rubaie, Administrative Investigation of the Public Service, Master Thesis, College of Law, University of Mosul, 2003.
- Al-Rafidain Law Journal, Volume 18, Year 20, Issue 63, 2018, issued by the College of Law, University of Mosul.
- Ali Khalil Ibrahim, the crime of a public employee subject to discipline in Iraqi law, a comparative study, Arab House, 1985.
- Ammar Abbas Al-Husseini, General and Administration Employee's Guide to Administrative Investigation and its Procedures, Al-Sinhouri Library, 2nd edition, Beirut, 2019.
- Bilal Amin Zain Al-Din, administrative discipline, a doctrinal study in the light of the rulings of the Supreme Administrative Court, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami'a, Alexandria, 2010.
- Decision of the State Shura Council No. (71/2007) on 10/10/2007, published in the decisions and fatwas of the State Shura Council for the year 2007 AD.
- Ghazi Faisal Mahdi, Explanation of the Provisions of the Law of Discipline of State Employees and the Socialist Sector No. (14) for the year 1991, Dar Al-Azza Press, Baghdad, 2001.
- Ibrahim Al-Mashhadi, The Judicial Authorities for Administrators, Al-Jahiz Press, Baghdad, 1991.
- Issam Abdel-Wahab Al-Barzanji, The Discretionary Authority of Judicial Administration and Control, Arab Renaissance House, 1971AD.
- Judge, Gesture Hamel Al-Ajili, Administrative investigation into the public office, its procedures, guarantees and authenticity, Al-Kitab Press, Baghdad, 1st edition, 2013 AD.
- Khaled Muhammad Mustafa Al-Mawla, the authority responsible for imposing disciplinary punishment on the public employee in Iraq, a comparative study, PhD thesis, College of Law, University of Mosul, 2005 AD
- Majed Hamdi Omar, End of Service of the Public Employee with the Power of Law, Dar Al-Fikr and Al-Law for Publishing and Distribution, Mansoura, 2017 AD.
- Mostafa Youssef, Disciplinary Officer of the Public Employee, Maarif Publishing Facility, Alexandria 2010.
- Othman Salman Ghaylan Al-Aboudi, Explanation of the Provisions of the State Employee Discipline Law No. (14) of 1991 as amended, 1st edition, 2010 AD.
- Penal Code No. (111) for the year 1969, as amended.
- Qidar Salih Al-Sa`, Idea of Reason in Administrative Decision, Master Thesis, College of Law, University of Mosul, 2002.
- Resolution of the State Consultative Council No. (129/2001) on October 26, 2008, published in the decisions and fatwas of the State Consultative Council for the year 2008AD.
- Saeed Hassab Allah Abdullah, Explanation of Criminal Procedure Law No.
- State and Public Sector Discipline Law No. (14) of 1991 amended.
- State Employee Discipline Law No. (69) of 1936 (repealed).
- The decision of the Basra Criminal Court in its capacity as discriminatory to the number (922 / TJ 1/2015) on 4/11/2015.
- The Resolution of the State Consultative Council No. (143 / Discipline / Excellence / 2008) on 3/7/2008, published in the decisions and fatwas of the State Consultative Council for the year 2008 AD.
- The State Shura Council Resolution No. (96/2006) on 12/5/2006, published in the decisions and fatwas of the State Shura Council for the year 2006 AD.