Disciplinary sanctions -A comparative study-

Section: RESEARCH
Published
Aug 4, 2025
Pages
390-418

Abstract

Like express disciplining punishments exercised by disciplining authority resulting in disciplining punishments as legally prescribed, there is a kind of punishment imposed by administration on an official without having recourse to disciplining procedures legally prescribed for the purpose of getting rid of an official with the slightest expense and in order not for its decision to be nullified by administrative judicial authorities, which results in the necessity of reinstating the official and settling his vocational position, This kind of punishment is called a veiled punishment Such a punishment is deemed to be a flagrant violation of and express encroachment upon the principle of legality observed by disciplining authorities in imposing restricted punishments and certain effects and restriction, as well as deviation from discretionary power behind which no public interest is sought perhaps the reason behind calling such punishments veiled is that administration body may find itself in from of an official who has certain ideas or exercises a conduct opposing its attitudes, and does not represent a disciplining line for which he can not be blamed, The forms of veiled punishment are numerous and represent a common method in the field of disciplining to the extent that it represents a phenomenon worthy of investigation for finding remedies for it, The difficulty of veiled punishment lies in the search for the intention of administration body, for administration claims that it attains public interest . The outer appearance represents that but its intention proves the contrary, There fore , judicial authorities depend on some circumstantial evidence, such as being a contemporary of the transference which overburdens the official it takes in to consideration the seriousness of management . The official has warranties against the veiled disciplinary punishments, sine he has the right to lodge a complaint before the administrative body issuing the decision, and has also the right to object before the competent court and claim compensation for the damage inflicted on him .

References

  1. -Abdel-Aziz Abdel Moneim Khalifa, Deviation of Power as a Reason for Abolishing Administrative Decision, National Center for Legal Publications, Cairo, 2010
  2. -Abdel-Aziz Abdel Moneim Khalifa, The Comprehensive Administrative Encyclopedia in the Abolition of the Administrative Decision and the Training of the Public Employee, C2, Knowledge Establishment, Alexandria,
  3. -Abdel-Aziz Abdel-Moneim Khalife, Public Disciplinary Guarantees, I, National Center for Legal Publications, 2008
  4. -Abdel-Fattah Abdel-Halim Abdel-Barr, Judicial Considerations and Appeals, Dar Al-Nahda Arabiya, Cairo,
  5. -Abdul Latif bin Hodeid al-Harbi, Guarantees of Public Service Discipline, Saudi Arabia, 2006
  6. -Abdul Mohsen Al-Salem, Convincing Disciplinary Sanctions between Legitimacy and Arbitrariness of Administration, i.
  7. -Abdul Qader Al-Shikhali, The Reasonable Penalty Problem in the Training of the Public Employee, Journal of Justice, Issue 3, Year 5, 1979
  8. -Abdul Wahab Al-Bandari, disciplinary sanctions for civil servants in the state and the public sector, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi, Cairo, B
  9. -Ali Hassan Ali, The Exaggeration in Penalty and its Effect on the Correctness of the Disciplinary Penalty, I, 2, p
  10. -Ali Saad Amran, Iraqi and Comparative Administrative Judiciary, Al-Sanhuri Library, Baghdad, 2011
  11. -Bahad Taha Sayed Hama Lau, Deviation of the Administrative Decision on the Base of Targets, Master's Message, Faculty of Law and Politics, University of Sulaymaniyah, 2014.
  12. -Bilal Amin Zein Al-Din, Administrative Discipline, 1, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami'i, Alexandria, 2010
  13. -Emad Melloukhia, The Disciplinary Guarantees of the Public Employee in the Islamic and Comparative Administrative System, New University House, Alexandria, 2012
  14. -Hassan Aswad Rajab Nasser, Disciplinary Sanctions for the Public Employee, Master 's Message, Faculty of Law, Mansoura University, 2016
  15. -Khalifa Salem Al-Jahmi, Judicial Control on the Proportionality of Punishment and Crime in Discipline, New University Press, Alexandria, 2009
  16. -Mahmoud Ramadan Mohammed Sahwan, Violation and Disciplinary Punishment and the Principle of Legitimacy, 1, Arab Center for Publishing and Distribution, Cairo, 2016
  17. -Majed Ragheb Al-Helw, Administrative Law, Publishing House and University Knowledge, Alexandria,
  18. -Majed Ragheb El Helou, Administrative Lawsuits, New University House, Alexandria, 2011,
  19. -Mazen Lilo Radhi, Administrative Law General Study Foundations and Principles of Iraqi Administrative Law, Hawar Press, Dohuk, 2007
  20. -Mohamed El-Nahas Mohamed Hassan, Disciplinary Discriminatory Sanctions, I, Dar Al-Nahda Al Arabiya, Cairo, 2010,
  21. -Mohamed Refaat Abdel Wahab, General Theory of Administrative Law, New University House, Alexandria, 2009
  22. -Mohammed Abu Daif Pasha Khalil, The Disciplinary System, New University House, Alexandria, 2013
  23. -Mohammed Majid Yacout, Explanation of the disciplinary law of the public function, Knowledge Establishment, Alexandria, 2006,
  24. -Mustafa Abu Zaid Fahmi, Elimination District, 2, Dar Al Fikr Al Arabi, Cairo, 1996
  25. -Mustafa Afifi, The Philosophy of Punitive Punishment and its Objectives, The Egyptian Public Library Press, 1976
  26. -Nada Mohammed Ghazal Qassem, Balance between the Effectiveness of the Administration and the Guarantees of the Public Employee in the Law of Discipline of State and Social Sector Employees No. 14 of 1991, Master's Thesis, Faculty of Law, University of Mosul, 1999
  27. -Noufan Al-Aqil Al-Ajrama, Authority for the Training of the Public Employee, 1, Dar Al-Thaqafa, Amman, 2007.
  28. -Ramadan Mohammed Batikh, Administrative Judiciary, District of Abolition, Dar Al-Nahda Al Arabiya, 2011
  29. -Rashid Mohammed Al-Fahali, The Legal System of Disciplinary Punishment and Guarantees in the United Arab Emirates, Dar Al-Nahda Al Arabiya, Cairo, 2015
  30. -Salliman Mohammad Al-Tamawi, Administrative Judiciary (Disciplinary Court), Third Book, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi, Cairo, 1995
  31. -Shafiq Abdul Majeed Al-Hadithi, Disciplined System of State Employees in Iraq, Master's Message, Faculty of Law and Politics, University of Baghdad, 1972
  32. -Tgreed Mohamed Kadouri Al-Naimi, The Principle of Legitimacy and its Impact on the System of Public Service Discipline, 1, Halabi Human Rights Publications, Beirut, 2013
  33. Bawadi Mustafa, Applied Punishment in the Field of Disciplinary, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tlemcen, Research published on the Internet https://platform.almanhal.com
  34. A set of decisions and advisory opinions of the State Consultative Council for 2007
  35. Act of 19 October 1946
  36. Fifth: The Internet webs
  37. Fourth: Judicial Groups
  38. French laws and regulations
  39. Iraqi laws and regulations
  40. Judge Hamed Al-Ajali, Administrative Investigation of the Public Function, 1, Al-Kitab Press, Baghdad, 2013
  41. Judge Jihad Safa, Research in Administrative Law, 1, Halabi Human Rights Publications, Beirut, 2009
  42. Law of 26 January 1984
  43. Law of 4 February 1959
  44. Law of Discipline of Employees of the State No. 14 of 1990
  45. Law of the State Council No. 17 of 2017
  46. Legal books
  47. References
  48. Second - Thesis
  49. Third: laws, regulations and instructions
Download this PDF file

Statistics