Judicial verdict as a source for the right of ownership

Section: RESEARCH
Issue
Vol. 25 No. 84 (2023): Volume 25 Issue 84
Published
Sep 1, 2023
Pages
43-86

Abstract

Generally, jurisprudence has not agreed to define judicial verdicts. Rather, jurists have taken this mission into two ways. Some defined it widely to be all decisions and resolutions destined to solve disputes raised in front of specialised authorities. Others defined it narrowly and accurately to be merely confined to court decisions while solving disputes raised by the parties of each case aiming to have a definite verdict from these courts to have this dispute solved. Similarly, four trends have tried to conceptualise court verdicts, each has depended upon a specific criterion to do so. Some counted on more than one criterion at the same time such as; formal, objective, and hybrid criterions. Additionally, another fourth trend has considered the function and effects of the same verdict as a criterion to conceptualise this judicial verdict. The judiciary verdict has a vital role to establish the right of ownership. This in turn takes two dimensions. On the one hand, the first exists when the verdict has a role with the sources of the right of ownership. Then this verdict becomes a means that establishes the right of ownership for an individual within a definite source among the other sources of this right. Evidently, this can be demonstrated within; the case of laying the bidding over a single partner through the division of common ownership by courts, or the case of laying the bidding over the possessor through implementing a real-estate mortgage. On the other hand, the second dimension can be illustrated when the verdict becomes a direct source for the right of ownership while all other sources are not in existence. Subsequently, the verdict is definitely becoming the direct source for the right of ownership. For instance, the cases of rescinding a real-estate sale, judicial acquisition, pre-emption, and the adhesion of a removable thing with another one in some cases.

References

  1. - Aram Muhammad Salih Saeed, The Legal Machine Between Theory and Practice, Master Thesis, (College of Law and Politics, University of Sulaymaniyah | 2008).
  2. - Brahimi Siham The idea of public benefit in expropriation Research published in the Journal of Sharia and Law, | Issued by the College of Law United Arab Emirates University | Issue (55),| for the year 2013,|.
  3. - Dr. Ibrahim Naguib Saad, Private Judicial Law, Part Two, (Mansha'at al-Maarif, Alexandria | without a year of publication).
  4. - Ibn Manzoor, Lisan Al-Arab, Part Three, (The Arab Heritage Revival House and the Arab History Foundation, Beirut, Lebanon | without a year of publication).
  5. - Iraqi Civil Law No. (40) of 1951, as amended.
  6. - Judge Abdul Karim Khader Aziz and Judge Awad Hussein Yassin, Al-Mukhtar from the jurisdiction of the Kirkuk Federal Court of Appeal in its discriminatory capacity for the years 2013-2018, Al-Sanhouri Library, Baghdad, 2019.
  7. - Decree of the dissolved Revolutionary Command Council No. 1198 of 1977 amended by Resolution 1426 of 1982.
  8. - Dr. Rakeh and Wat Ismail, and Rami, The Discretionary Truth, (Dar Al-Kutub Al-Qanuni, Egypt, Dar Shatat, UAE | 2015).
  9. - Decree of the dissolved Revolutionary Command Council No. (211) of 1978, amended by Resolution No. (978) of 7/24/1978.
  10. - Judge Shihab Ahmed Yassin, Al-Wajeez in explaining the law of appropriation, first edition, (The Legal Library, Baghdad | 2011).
  11. - Dr. Tariq Kazem Ajeel, The Mediator in the Sale Contract, Part One, Concluding the Contract, (Al-Sanhouri Library, Baghdad | 2008).
  12. - The Egyptian Civil Law No. (131) of 1948.
  13. - Diaa Sheet Khattab, The Art of Judgment, (Institute for Arab Research and Studies, Baghdad | 1974).
  14. - UAE Civil Transactions Law No. (5) of 1985.
  15. - Dr. Abdel-Hamid Al-Shawarbi, The Authoritativeness of Civil and Criminal Provisions in the Light of Jurisprudence and Judiciary Rulings, fourth edition, (Manshaat Al-Ma'arif, Alexandria | 1996).
  16. - Notice that Dr. Abd al-Razzaq al-Sanhouri, The Mediator in Explanation of Civil Law, Part VIII, The Right to Ownership, (Al-Halabi Human Rights Publications, Beirut | 2000).
  17. -Abd al-Razzaq al-Sanhouri, The Mediator in Explanation of Civil Law, Part Nine, Reasons for Acquiring Ownership, (Al-Halabi Human Rights Publications, Beirut | 2000).
  18. - Dr. Abdul Razzaq Al-Sanhouri, Theory of the Contract, Part Two, (Al-Halabi Human Rights Publications, Beirut | 1998).
  19. - Dr. Abd al-Razzaq al-Sanhouri, The Mediator in Explanation of Civil Law, Part Four, Contracts Responding to Ownership (Sale), (Al-Halabi Human Rights Publications, Beirut | 2000).
  20. - Dr. Abdul Qadir Al-Sheikhly, Judicial ruling from theory to application, (Dar Al-Thaqafa for publishing, Amman | 2014).
  21. - Asmaa Labed, Preemption as a Reason for Ownership, Master Thesis, (Faculty of Human Sciences, University of Oran, Algeria | 2016).
  22. - Dr. Jaber Muhanna Shebel, | The legality of the expropriation of private property and the guarantees that guarantee its protection A research published in the Journal of the Faculty of Law, Al-Nahrain University Issued by the Faculty of Law Al-Nahrain University, | Volume (17),| Number (2),| for the year 2015,|.
  23. - Hamad bin Abi Bakr Al-Razi, Al-Sahih, (Dar Al-Risala, Kuwait | 1983).
  24. - Ibrahim Abu Al-Naga, Original In-kind Rights in the Libyan Civil Law, first edition, (New University House, Alexandria | 1997).
  25. - The decision of the Federal Court of Cassation No. 978 on May 26, 2008, published on the Iraqi Legislation Base website, available on the Internet at www.iraqld.hjc.iq, the date of the visit, September 10, 2019.
  26. - The Iraqi Evidence Law No. (107) of 1979, as amended
  27. - Dr. Adnan Ibrahim Al-Sarhan, Explanation of the Provisions of Named Contracts in the Civil Transactions Law of the United Arab Emirates, Part One, Sale Contract, (Dar Wael Publishing, Amman | 2005).
  28. - Dr. Ali Hadi Al-Obeidi, In-kind Rights, (Dar Al-Thaqafa, Amman | 1999).
  29. - Dr. Muhammad Saeed Abdul Rahman, Judicial Ruling, Its Elements and Rules of Issuance, (Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jami`, Alexandria | 2008).
  30. - Dr. Muhammad Suleiman Al-Ahmad, Civil Thoughts, Civil Thoughts, (Publications of the Office of Thought and Awareness in the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan, Sulaymaniyah | 2009).
  31. - Dr. Mahmoud Al-Sayed Al-Tahiwi, The Theory of Judiciary Rulings, (Dar Al-Fikr Al-Jamai, Alexandria | 2006).
  32. - Dr. Mahmoud Muhammad Al-Kilani, Rules of Evidence and Implementation Provisions, (Dar Al-Thaqafa Amman | 2013).
  33. - Dr. Mufleh Awad Al-Qudah, Principles of Civil Trials and Judicial Organization, (Dar Al-Thaqafa, Amman | 2013).
  34. - Dr. Nabil Ibrahim Saad, Named Contracts, Part One, Sale, (Arab Renaissance House, Beirut | 1997).
  35. - Dr. Nabil Ibrahim Saad, The original in-kind rights, their provisions and sources, (New University House, Alexandria | 2006).
  36. - Dr. Nabil Ismail Omar, The Legal System of Judicial Judgment, first edition, (New University House, Alexandria | 2006).
  37. - Al-Munajjid in Language and Media, (Dar Al-Mashreq, Beirut | without a year of printing).
  38. - Amna Abd al-Karim Ali Ahmed, The Promise of Contract and its Applications in Civil Law, Master Thesis, (College of Law, Al-Nahrain University | 2008).
  39. - Court of Cassation Decision No. (626) on 12/21/1969, published on the Iraqi Legislation Base website, available on the Internet at www.iraqld.hjc.iq, date of visit 5/17/2019.
  40. - Dr. Ahmed Abu Al-Wafa, Theory of Judgments in the Law of Procedures, Part One, Fourth Edition, (Manshaat Al-Maarif, Alexandria | without a year of publication).
  41. - Dr. Amer Ashour Abdullah | The rule of less follows more in civil law A research published in (Journal of the College of Law for Legal and Political Sciences, | issued by the College of Law and Political Science, | University of Kirkuk, | Volume (4), | Issue (14), | Part Two, for the year | 2015 |.
  42. - Iraqi Implementation Law No. (40) of 1980, as amended
  43. - Nazih Kabbara, Public Domain and Private Domain, (Modern Book Foundation, Beirut | 2010).
  44. - Ahmad Mahmoud Khalil, Ahkam al-Shafaa Jurisprudence and Jurisprudence, (Manshaat al-Maarif, Alexandria | without a year of publication).
  45. - Decision of the Kurdistan Region Court of Cassation / Civil Authority No. 12 on 11/2/2007, published on the Iraqi Legislation Base website, available on the Internet at www.iraqld.hjc.iq, date of visit 9/10/2019.
  46. - Dr. Najm Al-Ahmad, | The legal concept of public interest in appropriation A research published in the Damascus University Journal of Economic and Legal Sciences Volume (29),| Number (2),| for the year 2013,|.
  47. - Hussein Abdel Qader Maarouf, The Idea of Formalism and its Applications in Contracts, PhD thesis, (College of Law, University of Baghdad | 2004).
  48. - Iraqi Real Estate Registration Law No. (43) of 1971, as amended.
  49. - Decision of the Kurdistan Region Court of Cassation / Expanded Commission No. 98 on 12/16/2008, published on the Iraqi Legislation Base website, available on the Internet at www.iraqld.hjc.iq, date of visit 5/10/2019.
  50. - Dr. Adam Wahib Al-Nadawi, Brief in the Law of Evidence, (House of Wisdom, Baghdad | 1990).
  51. - Iraqi Expropriation Law No. (12) of 1981.
  52. - Dr. Hassan Ali Al-Dhanoun, explaining the civil law, named contracts, the sale contract, (Al-Rabita Press, Baghdad | without a year of publication).
  53. - Iraqi Traffic Law No. (86) of 2004
  54. - The decision of the Baghdad / Al-Rusafa Federal Court of Appeal in its cassation capacity, No. 764/771 on 26/8/2010, published on the Iraqi Legislation Base website, available on the Internet at www.iraqld.hjc.iq, the date of the visit 5/10/2019.
  55. - Dr. Reda Abdel-Halim Abdel-Meguid, Al-Wajeez in Ownership and Ancillary In-kind Rights, (Center for Continuing Education, Faculty of Law, Benha University, Egypt | without a year of publication).
  56. - The decision of the Presidency of the Baghdad / Karkh Federal Court of Appeal / Cassation Commission, Judgment No. 745 / Human Rights / 2012 on 12/30/2012, published on the Iraqi Legislation Base website, available on the Internet at www.iraqld.hjc.iq, date of visit 5/10 /2019.
  57. - The new Traffic Law No. (8) for the year 2019 published in the Iraqi Gazette Issue (4550) on 5/8/2019, which will be implemented two months after its publication.
  58. - Dr. Saeed Mubarak, Explanation of the provisions of the Implementation Law No. (45) of 1980, second edition, (The Legal Library, Baghdad | 2007).
  59. - Iraqi Machinery Registration Law No. (36) of 1952.
  60. - The decision of the Nineveh Federal Court of Appeal No. 397 / BT / 2012 on 4/20/2012, published on the Iraqi Legislation Base website, available on the Internet at www.iraqld.hjc.iq, the date of the visit 5/10/2019.
  61. - Decision of the Egyptian Court of Cassation, Appeal No. 6908, Judicial Year 66, Technical Office 48, Session date 11/30/1997, published on kenanaonline.com, date of visit 5/15/2019.
  62. - Dr. Samir Abdel-Sayed Tanago, Contract of Sale, (Al-Wafaa Legal Library, Alexandria | 2009).
  63. - The Notary Clerks Law No. (33) of 1998.
  64. Books:
  65. Judicial Decisions and Sets of Judgments:
  66. Laws:
  67. Legal books:
  68. Master and Doctoral Theses:
  69. References
  70. Research:

Authors

Ziyad AL Jawaly

College of law and political science -Kirkuk University

Muhammad Al-Ahmad

College of Law and Political Science University of Sulaymaniyah

ORCID

Identifiers

https://doi.org/10.33899/rlawj.2019.126270.1039
Download this PDF file
PDF

Statistics