Liability for breaching building approval and planning permission: a comparative study
Abstract
The person wishing to build must adhere to the legal provisions predetermined by the legislation regulating urbanization and related to the building permit in terms of conditions for obtaining the building permit, whether these conditions relate to the request for the permission, which is a preliminary and necessary procedure that must be followed by the person concerned with the permission terms of submitting and the procedures that This request or the conditions related to the subject of the permit, i.e. construction works subject to this permit, pass by because the building permit is one of the most administrative means regulating one of the constitutional rights, which is the right of ownership guaranteed by the Constitution of the Republic of Iraq for the year 2005 B Item (first) of Article (23) must be stipulated by stipulating that (private property is protected, and the owner has the right to use it, exploit it and dispose of it, within the limits of the law), and item (second) of Article (27) by saying (is regulated by law, provisions relating to the preservation of state property And its management and the conditions for disposal thereof, and the limits within which it is not permissible to dispose of any of these funds), so the public interest, especially those that relate to construction, is what the legislator has hoped to interfere with by setting rules for this building and one of the most important of these rules is granting the building permit as it has become in most countries of the world One of the main means of respecting the rules for organizing and preserving the cultural character of cities is why Prevent the random construction that affects the health, aesthetic, and social aspects of residential areas, industrial and commercial areas. Therefore, we find that the Iraqi legislator has worked hard to put some texts in the regular and subsidiary legislation to address this issue, including the Municipal Administration Law No. (165) for the year 1964, as amended, and the Roads and Buildings System No. (44) for the year 1935, and the legislator was not satisfied with that, especially after the spread of the random construction phenomenon in The cities of Iraq in a manner that violates the foundations and controls of urban planning in a manner that represents a serious transgression of regulations and instructions. Therefore, we find that he issued specialized instructions for that which is the building permits system No. (2) for the year 2016, and if he violates those provisions, he becomes subject to legal accountability by the administration, and therefore has the right to impose an administrative penalty. Or non-management The goal of appropriate criminal or civil of the penalty.
References
- - Comparative Study, PhD thesis, College of Law, University of Babylon, 2020.
- - Iraqi legislation:
- - The canceled Municipalities Law No. 83 of 1931
- - G . vedel P . delvolve : droit administratif . T1 . P.U.F. ed 8 .themis . Paris. 1982
- - Amin Rahim Hamid: Legal Regulation for Building Permit
- - Dr. Ahmed Khurshid Hamidi / Raeda Yassin Khader: Legal Methods for Protection from Noise - A Comparative Study, published research in the Journal of the College of Law for Legal and Political Sciences, Tikrit University, Volume (5), Issue (15) 2016.
- - Dr. Ahmed Muhammad Faris Al-Nawaisa: The Principle of Non-retroactivity of Administrative Decisions, a Comparative Study, 1st Edition, Al-Hamid Publishing and Distribution House, Amman, Jordan, 2012.
- - Federal Court of Cassation Decision No. 807 / Human Rights on 12/19/1956, published in the Journal of the Legal Notation Bureau, No. 1,1966.
- - French Civil Code No. 1804.
- - Imam al-Alamamah Abi al-Fadl Jamal al-Din Muhammad bin Makram (Ibn Manzur): Lisan al-Arab, Bab al-Jim, volume three, without the name of a printing press, Dar al-Hadith, Cairo, 2003.
- - Roads and Buildings Regulation No. 44 of 1935, as amended.
- - The ruling of the Supreme Administrative Court in Appeal No. 272 for the year (27) on 2/14/1987, the set of legal principles decided by the Supreme Administrative Court, the thirty-third year, C1, p. 807, published on the website New.aspx Print / WWW.laweg. net Visit date 3/3/2020.
- - Dr. Ali Muhammad Khalaf Al-Fatlawi: The notion of unfamiliar or obscene neighborhood harms as a legal basis for the responsibility of the perpetrator of environmental damage - an analytical study between the Iraqi and Egyptian laws, published research in the Journal of the University Islamic College, Volume (2), Issue (37).
- - Dr. Thanoun Suleiman Yunus: The Fall of Administrative Decisions, C1, without specifying an edition, Diaspora Press, Legal Books House, Egypt, 2015.
- - Dr. Ghanam Muhammad Ghannam: Criminal Responsibility for Building Builders (Contractor - Building Engineer - Building Owner), a research published in the Journal of Law, Academic Publication Council, Kuwait University, Issue (4), Year 19, 1995
- - Dr. Sami Gamal El-Din: Fundamentals of Administrative Law, Part 2, University Press, without specifying an edition, Alexandria, 1996.
- - Dr. Soliman Muhammad Al-Tamawi: Al-Wajeez in Administrative Law, without the name of a printing press, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi, Cairo, 1979.
- - Muhammad Muhammad Metwally: The extent of the administrations authority to withdraw its administrative decisions, a research published in the Journal of Government Cases Management, Egypt, Issue (1), Year (16), 1972.
- - Dr. Mahmoud Helmy: The End of the Administrative Decision, a research published in the Journal of Administrative Sciences, the Egyptian Division of the International Institute for Administrative Sciences, Issue (1), Year (6), 1964.
- - Dr. Saja Mohamed Abbas: The role of environmental administrative control in protecting the beauty of cities, 1st Edition, Arab Center for Publishing and Distribution, Egypt, 2017.
- - Dr. Musleh Al-Sarayreh: The Legal System for Building Permits, A Comparative Study of French Law and Jordanian Law, a research published in the Journal of Law, the Academic Publication Council, Kuwait University, Issue (4), Year (25), 2001.
- - Saad Jaryan Al-Tamimi: Legal Principles in the Judiciary of the Federal Court of Cassation - Civil Section - for the years 2016-2017, Dar Al-Sanhouri, without specifying an edition, Baghdad, 2018.
- - Dr. Ahmed Morgan: Building and Demolition Work Permits Between Building Legislation, Military Orders, Ministerial Decisions, and Judicial Rulings Events, without a printing press, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2002.
- - Dr. Hani Ali Al-Tahrani: Rules and Effects of Withdrawing the Administrative Decision with a Focus on the Judiciary of the Supreme Court of Justice, a research published in the Journal of Law, Academic Publication Council, Kuwait University, Issue (2), Year 28, 2004
- - Dr. Shab Touma Mansour: Administrative Law, Book Two, First Edition, Iraq Publishing House, Baghdad, 1980.
- - Dr. Shorouk Abbas Fadel / Dr. Asmaa Saber Alwan: Civil Liability for the Adversities of Unfamiliar Neighborhood, 1st Edition, Arab Center for Publishing and Distribution, Egypt, 2016.
- - Dr. Shams El-Din Al-Wakeel: The summary in the entry for the study of law, the legal base - the general theory of right, first edition, Ma'arif Foundation, Alexandria, without a year of publication.
- - Qassem Fakhry Al-Rabaei: Principles of the Federal Court of Cassation - Civil Section, 1st Edition, without publishing house, 2018.
- - Civil Law No. 40 of 1951 as amended. 3- Municipalities Law No. 165 of 1964, as amended.
- Instructions to Facilitate Municipal Administration Law No. (2) of 2001.
- - Cyr Cambier : droit administratf . bruxelles mainson Ferdinand larcier . s. a39 . rue des minims . 1968
- - Dr. Ahmed Mahmoud Saad: An Extrapolation of the Rules of Civil Liability in Environmental Pollution Disputes, 1st Edition, Arab Renaissance House, Cairo, 1994.
- - Dr. Ismail Sa`sa Al-Badiri / Hawraa Haider Adham: Legal methods for protecting the environment from pollution, a comparative study, a research published in the Investigator Al-Hilli Journal of Legal and Political Sciences, College of Law, University of Babylon, Issue (2), Year (6), 2014
- - Egyptian Penal Code No. (58) of 1937, as amended.
- - Federal Court of Cassation Decision No. 807 Jurists / 1965, on 12/19/1965, published in the Journal of Legal Notation, First Issue, 1966.
- - Nashwan bin Said: Al Wasit Lexicon, without the name of a printing press, Cairo, 1960.
- - Salma Talal Abdel Hamid: Decisions that may be withdrawn and canceled without being bound by the deadline for appealing a PhD thesis, Faculty of Law, Nahrain University, 2010.
- - The ruling of the Supreme Administrative Court in Appeal No. 2764 for the year (34) on 25/1/1994, the set of legal principles decided by the Supreme Administrative Court, the thirty-ninth year, C1, p. 733, published on the website New.aspx Print / WWW.laweg. net Visit date 3/13/2020.
- - Dr. Abdel Hakam Fouda: Invalidation in Civil Law and Special Laws, University Press, without specifying an edition, Alexandria, 1993.
- - Dr. Abdel Hamid Al-Shawarby: Municipal Legislations, 5th Edition, Al Ma'arif Establishment, Alexandria, 1997.
- - Dr. Abd al-Rahman Ali Hamzah: The Harms of Unfamiliar Neighborhood and Responsibility for It - A Comparative Study of Islamic Jurisprudence and Positive Law, Without the Name of a Printing Press, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, 2006.
- - Dr. Abdel Aziz Abdel Moneim Khalifa: Administrative Termination of Administrative Decisions - Withdrawal and Abolition of the Administrative Decision, First Edition, Modern University Office, Alexandria, 2015.
- - Dr. Alaa Ibrahim Mahmoud: Protection of acquired rights arising from the administrative decision, a comparative study, The New University House, without specifying an edition, Alexandria, 2018.
- - Dr. Fayez Hajj Shaheen: French Civil Law in Arabic, Dalouz's French Edition, Center for Law Studies for the Arab World, Lebanon, 2009.
- - Dr. Kamal Muhammad Al-Amin: Judicial Supervision of Building and Construction Work Permits, 2nd Edition, Dar Al-Ayyam Publishing and Distribution, Amman, Jordan, 2018.
- - Dr. Majid Ragheb Al-Helou: Administrative Law, University Press, without specifying an edition, Alexandria, 1998.
- - Dr. Mazen Leilo Radhi: The General Theory of Administrative Decisions and Contracts, Brothers Press, without specifying an edition, Knowledge Foundation, Alexandria, 2012.
- - Dr. Maher Abu Al-Enein: The Evolution of the Abolition Judiciary and the Role of the Administrative Judiciary in Protecting Public Rights and Freedoms and Human Rights An applied study of the role of the administrative judge in Egypt, without the name of a printing press and publishing house.
- - Abdel Nasser Abdel Aziz Ali: Criminal Responsibility of Construction Workers, PhD thesis, Faculty of Law, Mansoura University, Egypt, 2011.
- - Dr. Bakhit Muhammad Bakhit Ali: The threatening fine before the civil judiciary, substantive and procedural aspects, without the name of a printing press, New University House, Alexandria, 2008.
- - Dr. Ozden Hussein Daza Yi / Dr. Imad Fattah Ismail: Criminal Responsibility for Building Violations in Iraqi Law - A Comparative Study, published research in Tikrit University Journal of Law, Year (2), Issue (2), 2018.
- - Egyptian Civil Law No. 131 of 1948, as amended
- - Instructions to Facilitate Municipalities Administration Law No. (10) of 2001.
- - Iraqi Federal Court of Cassation Decision No. 1578 / Appeals Authority on 9/28/2016, Sa`d Jaryan Al-Tamimi: Legal Principles in the Judiciary of the Federal Court of Cassation - Civil Section - for the years 2016-2017, Dar Al-Sanhouri, without specifying an edition, Baghdad, 2018 .
- - Maurice Bourjol : droit administratif le action administratif . masson et cie . editions . paris . 1972
- - The ruling of the Supreme Administrative Court in Egypt in Appeal No. 5083 for the year (51) on December 8, 2007, the set of legal principles decided by the Supreme Administrative Court Fifty-third year, C1, p. 302 published on the website New.aspx Print / WWW. laweg.net Date of visit 3/9/2020.
- - Dr. Maher Saleh Allawi Al-Jubouri: Mediator in Administrative Law, Ibn Al-Atheer House for Printing, without specifying an edition, University of Mosul, 2009.
- - Dr. Maher Saleh Allawi: Administrative Decision, Dar Al-Hikma Printing and Publishing, without specifying an edition, Baghdad, 1991.
- - Dr. Muhammad Ahmad Fateh al-Bab: The Legal System for Building Provisions in Egypt, 2nd Edition, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 1999-2000.
- - Dr. Muhammad Saeed Hussein: Withdrawal of the administrative decision between the discretionary power and the restricted authority, without the name of a printing press, Dar Al-Nahda Al-Arabiya, Cairo, 2005.
- - Muhammad Taha Al-Bashir / Dr. Ghani Hassoun Taha: Real Rights, Part 1, without the name of a printing press, Cairo, without a year of publication.
- - Dr. Muhammad Maher Abu Al-Enein, Dr. Atef Muhammad Abd al-Latif: The Development of Administrative Licenses in the Judiciary and Ifta of the State Council Judicial Oversight of Decisions Related to Building Permits, Volume (4), i2, National Center for Legal Issues, Egypt, 2018.
- - Dr. Muhammad Maher Abu Al-Enein, Dr. Atef Muhammad Abd Al-Latif: The Development of Administrative Licenses in the Judiciary and Ifta of the State Council, The Legislative and Judicial Framework for Building, Raising and Demolition Permits, Volume (2), 2nd Edition, National Center for Legal Issues, Egypt, 2018.
- - Dr. Mahmoud Naguib Hosni: Explanation of the Lebanese Penal Code, General Section, Volume Two, 3rd Edition, Al-Halabi Human Rights Publications, Beirut, 1998.
- - Dr. Munther Abdul-Hussein Al-Fadl: The social function of private property in Islamic law and Iraqi law, without the name of a printing press, place and year of publication.
- - Dr. Muhammad Al-Tayeb Abdel-Latif: The Licensing and Notification System in Egyptian Law (a Comparative Study), Authorship Press, without specifying an edition, Egypt, 1957.
- - The Iraqi Penal Code No. (111) of 1969, as amended. 5 - Public Roads Law No. (35) of 2002
- - Courrier Juridique des Affaires socials Sociales et des Sports.No 86 MarsAvril
- - Deeb Fatna: The Legal System for Building Permits in Light of Executive Decree No. 15/19, research published in the Journal of Construction and Building Legislation, Ibn Khaldoun University, Algeria, Issue (3), 2017.
- - Dr. Jamil El-Sharkawy: The theory of invalidity of legal action in Egyptian civil law, without the name of a printing press, Cairo, 1956.
- - Iraqi Federal Court of Cassation Decision No. 3178 / Appellate Body on November 28, 2016, Qasim Fakhri Al-Rubaie: Principles of the Federal Court of Cassation - Civil Section, First Edition, without publishing house, 2018.
- - Muhammad Othman Jibril: Administrative License, Comparative Study, Doctoral Thesis, Faculty of Law, Ain Shams University, 1992.
- - The amended French construction and housing law of 1977, published on the website https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr
- - The Executive Regulations for the Building Law promulgated by Law No. 144 of 2009
- - The ruling of the French Council of State, ICTOBER 20/201/11 CE 40878 published on the website Accuil conseil-etat.fr Date of visit 3/9/2020
- - Dr. Muhammad Bahi Abu Yunis: A threatening fine as a means to force the administration to implement administrative rulings, without the name of a printing press, New University Publishing House, Alexandria, 2001.
- - Muhammad Hamdi Salman: The Authority's Authority and Responsibility to Combat Abuses, A Study in Light of the Iraqi Legal System, 1st Edition, Beirut, 2018.
- - Dr. Muhammad Saad Fouda: The General Theory of Administrative Punishments, a comparative jurisprudential study, without the name of a printing press, New University House, Alexandria, 2010.
- - Dr. Hamad Maher Abu Al-Enein: Administrative Licenses and Related and Related Decisions in the State Council Wafa Judiciary, Analytical Study, Volume 2, 2nd Edition, Abu Al-Majd House for Printing, Egypt, 2006.
- - Dr. Hamed Sharif Mustafa: Appeal against administrative decisions in buildings before the courts of the State Council, without the name of a printing press, Egypt, 2006.
- - Dr. Saab Naji Abboud: Lectures on the Administration Authority for the Protection of Natural Reserves, given to PhD students at the Faculty of Law, University of Karbala, 2018.
- - French Decree No. 131-1 of February 10, 2016 amending the French law published on the website http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr.
- - French sanctions in 1992 and in force in 1994 as amended.
- - Hilla Court of First Instance Decision No. 4442 / B / 2013 on 12/16/2013 unpublished.
- - Nasegha Faisal: Control of General Administrative Penalties in the Algerian Legal System, PhD thesis, Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Mohamed Khoudair, Biskra, Algeria, 2011.
- - The judgment of the French Council of State C.E.Section.October 7.2016 Municipality of BORDEAUX.NO, 395211, A published on the website Accuil conseil-etat.fr
- - Decree No. (617) of (17) March 2018 amending the French Urban Planning Law, published on the website http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr.
- - Dr. Amer Ashour Abdullah, Awad Hussein Yassin: Civil Responsibility for the Municipalitys Abuse in Granting Building Permits, a research published in Tikrit University Journal of Law, Volume (5), Year (8), Issue (20), 2016.
- - Dr. Hamed Al-Sharif Mustafa: Building Fairies, 1st Edition, University Press, Alexandria, 1995.
- - Law No. 204 of 2004 amending the French Penal Code published on the website of the French Legislation Database http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr
- - Noor Al-Hoda Jamil: Management Authority in the Field of Urban Planning in Iraq (a comparative study), Master Thesis, College of Law and Politics, University of Basra, 2017.
- - Building Permits System No. (2) for the year 2016
- - Dr. Abdel Halim Bin Badah: Building Permit Violations in Algerian Legislation between Criminalization and Criminal Follow-up, a research published in the Journal of Reconstruction and Building Legislation, Ibn Khaldoun University, Algeria, Issue (7), 2018
- - Dr. Hassan Kirah: Introduction to Law, 5th Edition, Al Ma'arif Institute, Alexandria, 1974.
- - Dr. Azri Al-Zein: The Legal System for Building Permits in Algerian Legislation, a research published in the Journal of Human Sciences, Mohamed Khaider University, Biskra, Algeria, Issue VIII, 2005.
- - Hosni Darwish Abd Al-Hamid: The end of the administrative decision by other than the judiciary, without the name of a printing press, Dar Al-Fikr Al-Arabi, Cairo, without a year of publication.
- - Alaa Nafeh Kattafa: The role of administrative sanctions in protecting the environment, a comparative study, a research published in the Journal of Al-Kufa for Legal and Political Sciences, College of Law, University of Kufa, Volume (1), Issue (15), year 2013.
- - Dr. Dasah Nekah Radoud Muhammad: Administrative Control for Environmental Protection, a comparative analytical study, Diaspora Press, without specifying an edition, Dar Al-Kotob Al-Legal, Egypt, 2012.
- A- In Iraq
- B- In the comparison countries:
- Fifth - judicial rulings:
- First - linguistic dictionaries:
- Fourth - Research:
- Other legislations:
- References
- Regulations and Instructions:
- Second - Legal References:
- Seventh - Legislation, Regulations and Instructions: *
- Sixth: forign references
- Third - messages and dissertations: