Property is obsolete property in English law -Comparative analytical study-
Abstract
The Disseisin of land is one of the well-established ways of trespassing to other's land included in the English common law, which is unwritten and based upon judicial precedents. It is worth-bearing in mind that it is considered as the intentional tort known as the trespass to land. Many legal effects may arise from The Disseisin of land, the most considerable of which is that it does not give the usurper or disseisor , in general, any proprietary interests. But he or she can exceptionally have good color of title, and can even acquire the ownership of the usurped estate by adverse possession and acquisitive prescription. It is also worth-mentioning thatIslamic jurisprudence regulated The usurpation or disseisin of landprecisely, although some of its schools of doctrine restrict the usurpation to personal, rather than real property. It is to be noted also that the Iraqi civil law No.40 of 1951 has been highly affected by the Islamic jurisprudence in regulating the usurpation or disseisin of land explicitly. And this study supposes that there are some similarities between the English law and the Islamic jurisprudence, as far as the disseisin of land, its acquisition by possession, and some other effects arising from it are concerned.
References
- - Dr. Habib Idris Issa and Dr. Akram Mahmoud Hussein al-Badaw. Ensuring that a comparative analytical study is conducted. Research published in the AL Rafidain law journal,college of law, , Universityof Mosul . Volume 17. Number 61. Year 19. December 2017.
- . Laws.
- - George E. Woodbine. The Origins of The Action of Trespass. Yale Law Journal. Article1. Volume 34. Issue 4. 1925.
- - https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/adverse-possession-of-1-unregistered-land-and-2-registered-land/practice-guide-5-adverse-possession-of-1-unregistered-and-2-registered-land-where-a-right-to-be-registered-was-acquired-before-13-october-2003
- - The Land Registration Act 1925
- - Iraqi Civil Code No. (40) of 1951.
- Abu al-Hassan Ali bin Abdul Salam Al-Tushi. delight in explaining the masterpiece. Part two. First edition. Beirut Scientific Books House. Lebanon.1998.
- Alison Clarke & Paul Kohler. Property Law, Commentary and Materials. First Edition. Cambridge University Press. 2005.
- Dr. Hassan Ali Al-Dinun. Happy in explaining the civil law. Part two. Error, first edition. Wael Publishing House. 2006.
- Salman Pyatt. Iraqi civil justice. Part two. The local copyright company. Baghdad. 1962.
- - https://www.lawteacher.net/cases/buckinghamshire-cc-v-moran.php
- Dr. Abdul Majeed al-Hakim, Summary in the Commentary on Civil Law, Part 1 in Sources of Commitment with Comparison with Islamic Jurisprudence, Al-Ahli Publishing Company, Baghdad, 1963.
- John Cooke. Law of Tort. Fourth Edition. Financial Times. Pitman Publishing, 1999.
- Shamseddine Sheikh Mohammed Arafa Al-Desouki. Al-Desouki's footnote on the big explanation. Part four. The Arab Book Revival House, Issa Al-Babi Al-Halabi & Co. Without a year's publication.
- - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_Registration_Act_2002
- Dr. Adnan Ibrahim Al-Sarhan and Dr. Nouri Hamad Khater, Civil Law Explanation, Sources of Personal Rights, Commitments, Comparative Study, Culture Publishing and Distribution House, Amman, 2009
- John. E. Cribbet and Corwin W. Johnson. Principles of The Law of Property. Third Edition. The Foundation Press, INC. 1989.
- Shamseddine bin Mohammed Al-Khatib Al-Sharbini. A singer who needs to know the meanings of the syllabus. Part two. First edition. Knowledge House Beirut Lebanon. 1997.
- Dr. Esmat Abdel Majid Bakr. The general theory of obligations. Part one. Sources of commitment. First edition. Memory for publishing and distribution. Baghdad. 2011.
- John Wilman, Brown, GCSE Law, Ninth Edition, Thomson Sweet and Maxwell, 2005.
- Sheikh Nizam and a group of Indian scholars flags. The Indian fatwas are known as the World's Fatwas in the doctrine of Imam Abu Hanifa al-Nu'man. Part five. First edition. Beirut Scientific Books House. Lebanon. 2000.
- Aladdin Abu Bakr bin Massoud Al-Kassani Al-Hanafi. The manufactures of the manufactures in the order of the canons. Part 10. Second edition. Scientific Books House. Beirut, Lebanon. 2003.
- Dr. Esmat Abdel Majid Bakr. Default liability in Arab civil laws. Zain Human Rights Publications. Beirut. 2016.
- Joseph William Singer. Property. Fifth Edition. Wolters Kluwer. New York. 2017.
- Ali Al-Light. Provisions of legitimate transactions. Cairo Arab Thought House. 2008.
- Dr. Mohammed Abdul Jawad Mohammed. Possession and obsolescence in Islamic jurisprudence compared to positive law. Knowledge Facility in Alexandria. 1977.
- Linda Edwards. Stanley Edwards. Patricia Kirtley Wells, Tort Law, Fifth Edition, DELMAR, 2012.
- Ali ibn Abu Bakr al-Marginani Burhanuddin Abu al-Hasan. Al-Hidaya explained the beginning of the beginner with the explanation of the Abdul Hay Al-Kanawi. Part six. First edition. Administration of the Qur'an and Islamic Sciences - Pakistan. 1417 H.
- Dr. Mohieddin Hilal Al-Sarhan, Jurisprudence and Its Role in Enriching Modern Legislation, Baghdad University, 1978.
- Michael Jones, Textbook on Torts, Oxford University Press, Eighth Edition. 2005.
- Fakhreddin Osman bin Ali Al-Zelai. Sharh kanz al daqaaeq and the margin of the footnote of Chalabi. Part five. The Great Princely Press in Boulaq Of Egypt. 1314 E.
- Mustafa Majid. Explain the Real Estate Registration Act No. 43 of 1971. Part one. Second edition. Law Library. Baghdad. 2008.
- Paula Giliker and Silas Beckwith. Tort, Forth Edition, Sweet & Maxwell, Thomson Reuters, 2011.
- Dr. Munther al-Fadl, mediator in the commentary on civil law, a comparative study of Islamic jurisprudence and Arab and foreign civil laws, reinforced by the opinions of jurists and the rulings of the judiciary, Aras Publications, Erbil, 2006.
- Muhammad Abu Zahra. Property and the theory of the contract in Islamic law. Arab Thought House. Cairo. 1977.
- Robert Abbey and Mark Richards. Property Law 2018-2019. Tenth Edition. Oxford University Press. 2018
- Dr. Yasin Mohammed Al-Jubouri. Brief in explaining Jordan's civil law. Part two. Effects of personal rights. Provisions of obligations. Culture House for publishing and distribution. Oman. 2003.
- Muhammad al-Kharshi Abu Abdullah- Ali al-Adawi. Al-Kharshi explained the acronym of Sidi Khalil and his margin of al-Adawi's entourage. The Grand Princely Press in Bulaq Of Egypt.1317 H.
- Roger J. Smith. Property Law Cases And Materials. Fifth Edition. Pearson Education Limited. 2012.
- Muhammad Amin ibn Omar Abidin, alias Ibn Abidin. Al-Mahtar replied to the chosen elm to explain the enlightenment of the sight. Part 9. The House of the World of Books. Riyadh. 2003.
- Roger J. Smith. Property Law. Eighth Edition. Pearson Education Limited. 2014.
- - http://e-lawresources.co.uk/Land/J-A-Pye--Oxford--Ltd-v-Graham.php
- - Jeffrey E. Stake. The Uneasy Case for Adverse Possession. Articles by Maurer Faculty. Maurer School of Law: Indiana University. 2001.
- - The Land Registration Act 2002
- - Egyptian Civil Law No. (131) of 1948.
- Abu al-Walid Mohammed bin Ahmed bin Ahmed bin Rushd al-Qartabi al-Maliki. Fatwas of Ibn Rushd. First edition. The House of the Islamic West. Beirut, Lebanon. 1987.
- Barbara Harvey, John Marston. Cases and Commentary on Tort. Sixth Edition. Oxford University Press. 2009 .
- Dr. Hassan Ali Al-Dinun and Dr. Mohammed Saeed Al Rahu. brief in the general theory of commitment. Part one, sources of commitment. A comparative study of Islamic and comparative jurisprudence. First edition. Wael Publishing House. Oman. 2002.
- Journal of Legislation and Justice. Year 10. First issue (January-June) 2018.
- Mohammed bin Ahmed bin Jazi Al-Gharnati. The jurisprudential laws in summarizing the Doctrine of the Malikis and the warning on the doctrine of Shafi'i, Hanafi, and Hanbali. Dar Ibn Hazm. Beirut, Lebanon. 2013.
- Samantha Hepburn. Principles of Property Law. Second Edition. Cavendish Publishing. London. 2001.
- Mohammed bin Ahmed bin Mohammed bin Ahmed bin Rushd, grandson. The beginning of the hardworking and the end of the frugal. Part four. First edition. Ibn Taymiyyah Library. Cairo. 1415 E.
- Simon Deakin, Angus Johnston and Basil Markesinis. Markesinis and Deakins Tort Law. Seventh Edition .Clarendon press. Oxford , 2013.
- Mohammed bin Ismail al-Manaani. Ways of peace explain the achievement of the rules of judgment. Part three. First edition. Knowledge Library for Publishing and Distribution, Riyadh.2006.
- Steven L. Emanuel. Emanuel law outlines. Property. Aspen publishing. New York.2004.
- Muhammad bin Ali bin Mohammed Al-Shawkani. Neil Al-Otar explained the news picker. House of International Ideas. Lebanon. 2004.
- Muhammad bin Ali bin Muhammad bin Abdul Rahman al-Hanafi al-Hasfi. The chosen elm explained the enlightenment of the eyes and the mosque of the sea. First edition. Beirut Scientific Books House. 2002.
- Mohammed bin Mohammed bin Abdulrahman al-Maliki, Moroccan hattab Abu Abdullah. Galilee's talents in the brief explanation of Sheikh Khalil. Part six. First edition. Dar Al-Radwan. Nouakchott, Mauritania. 2010.
- Muwaffaq al-Din Abu Mohammed Abdullah bin Ahmed bin Mohammed bin Qadma. Singer. Part seven. Third edition. World of Books For Printing, Publishing and Distribution. Riyadh. 1997.
- Dr. Wahba Al-Zahili. Islamic jurisprudence and its evidence. Part five. Second edition. Dar al-Fidaa for printing, distribution and publishing in Damascus. 1985.
- - http://e-lawresources.co.uk/Land/Powell-v-McFarlane.php
- - John A. Makdisi. The Islamic Origins of The Common Law. North Carolina Law Review. Article2. Volume77. Number 5. 1999.
- - The Limitation Act 1980
- - Iraqi Real Estate Registration Law No. (43) of 1971
- Abu Abdullah Malik bin Anas bin Malik. Becoming. The Big Blog. Part 13. Ministry of Islamic Affairs, Endowments, Da'wa and Guidance. Saudi Arabia. 1324 H.
- Barlow Burke, Joseph Snoe. Property . Fifth Edition. Wolters Kluwer, New York. 2016.
- Dr. Hammad Shield. General Theory of Obligations, First Section, Sources of Commitment, Sanhouri Library, Beirut, 2016.
- - https://hklandlaw.wordpress.com/2011/06/10/adverse-possession-no-need-to-have-a-positive-intention-to-defeat-the-rights-of-the-formal-title-owner/
- - Percy Bordwell. Disseisin and adverse Possession. Yale Law Journal. Article 3. Volume 33. Issue 2. 1923.
- Abu Muhammad Ali bin Ahmed bin Saeed bin Hazm al-Andalusi. Local antiquities. Part six. First edition. Scientific Books House. Beirut, Lebanon. 2003 .
- Catherine Elliott & Frances Quinn, Tort law, Eighth Edition, Longman, Pearson , 2011.
- Dr. Darah Hammad Abd. Original in-kind rights. The right of ownership and its subsidiary rights. Dar Al-Sanhouri. Beirut, Lebanon. 2018.
- - https://swarb.co.uk/bp-properties-ltd-v-buckler-ca-31-jul-1987/
- Ahmed Mohammed Al-Zarqa. Explain the rules of jurisprudence. Second edition. Dar al-Qalam Damascus. 1989.
- Charles Harpum, Stuart Bridge, Martin Dixon. The Law of real Property. Eighth Edition. Sweet& Maxwell. London. 2012.
- Salim Rustam Baz Al-Lebanese. Explain the magazine. Third edition. Al-Halabi human rights publications. Beirut, Lebanon. Without a year of printing.
- - https://hklandlaw.wordpress.com/2011/10/12/unilateral-licence-can-stop-time-running-for-adverse-possession/
- Christopher Wadlow, The Law of Passing-off, Unfair Competition by Misrepresentation, Fourth Edition, Sweet& Maxwell, Thomson Reuters, 2011.
- Dr. Ghani Hassoun Taha, Mohammed Taha al-Bashir, Rights in Kind, Part 1, Ministry of Higher Education and Scientific Research, 1980.
- Taqi al-Din Abu Bakr bin Muhammad al-Husni al-Husayni al-Damascene al-Shafei. Enough good people to solve the abbreviation. Shorouk Foundation for Translation and Publishing. Mansoura. 2013.
- - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_possession
- Donald W. Sutherland. The Assize of the Novel Disseisin. Oxford at Clarendon Press. 1973.
- Dr. Abdul Razzaq Ahmed Al-Sanhouri. The mediator in explaining the civil law. Part one. The theory of commitment in general. Sources of commitment. Contract - illegal work - enrichment for no reason - law. Knowledge Facility in Alexandria. 2004.
- Jalaluddin Abdul Rahman bin Abu Bakr al-Suyuti Abu al-Fadl. Semi-analogies and analogues in the rules and branches of shafi'i jurisprudence. Part six. First edition. Scientific Books House Beirut.1983.
- - https://swarb.co.uk/kelsen-v-imperial-tobacco-co-of-great-britain-and-northern-ireland-ltd-1957/
- Dr. Abdul Razzaq Ahmed Al-Sanhouri. The mediator in explaining the civil law. Part 9. Reasons for gaining ownership with the original in-kind rights of ownership (right of use and right of easement). Knowledge Facility in Alexandria.2004.
- Elizabeth Cooke. Modern Studies In Property Law. Volume Four. Hart Publishing. 2007.
- Zainaldin Ibn Najim Hanafi. The sea is a commentary on the treasure of the minutes, and with it the footnotes called the Grant of the Creator on the Sea of The Rheat. Part eight. Beirut Scientific Books House. Lebanon.1997.
- - https://www.thefreedictionary.com/disseisin.
- Dr. Abdul Razzaq Ahmed Al-Sanhouri, Sources of The Right to Islamic Jurisprudence, Comparative Study of Western Jurisprudence, Part 1. Introduction- Contract formula. Al-Halabi human rights publications. Beirut. 1998.
- F.H. Lawson and Bernard Rudden. The Law of Property. First Edition. Oxford University Press. 2002 .
- Shamseddine Al-Sarkhsi. AL Mbsoot. Part six. Knowledge House Beirut. 1989.
- A. Books of Islamic Jurisprudence
- B. Legal books.
- C. Published Research
- D. Collections of judicial rulings.
- First: Books.
- First: sources in Arabic.
- Fourth : Internet websites
- Second: Laws
- Second: Sources in English.
- The references
- Third: Papers of Research